Most laws in the United States are written by elected representatives. But in many states, citizens do not have to wait for lawmakers to act. Through citizen initiatives, referendums, and recalls, voters can propose laws, overturn legislation, amend state constitutions, and remove officials from office.

These tools of direct democracy are sometimes called people-led legislation. This guide explains how they work, where they are available, their strengths and weaknesses, and how citizens can use them.

A Brief History of Direct Democracy in America

Direct democracy has deep roots in American history, from New England town meetings to the Progressive Era reforms of the late 1800s and early 1900s. Reformers at the time were frustrated by legislatures they believed were controlled by railroads, banks, and political machines.

In 1898, South Dakota became the first state to adopt the citizen initiative and referendum. Oregon followed in 1902, and its system became so influential that it was known as the “Oregon System.”

Over the next two decades, many states, mostly in the West and Midwest, adopted similar processes.

The Main Tools of People-Led Legislation

1. The Citizen Initiative

An initiative allows citizens to propose a new law or constitutional amendment by collecting a required number of voter signatures. If enough valid signatures are submitted, the measure goes before voters.

There are two types:

Initiatives can create either:

2. The Popular (Veto) Referendum

A popular referendum allows citizens to challenge a law the legislature has already passed. If enough signatures are gathered within a set time after the law passes, the law is placed on the ballot, and voters decide whether to keep or repeal it.

3. The Legislative Referral

A legislative referral occurs when lawmakers place a measure on the ballot for voters to decide. In nearly every state, constitutional amendments proposed by the legislature must be approved by voters.

4. The Recall

A recall allows voters to remove an elected official before the end of their term. Citizens collect signatures to trigger a recall election. Around 19 states allow recall of state officials, and many more allow recall of local officials.

Where Are Citizen Initiatives Available?

About half of the states offer some form of statewide citizen initiative or popular referendum. These processes are most common in Western states. Many states that do not allow statewide initiatives still allow them at the city or county level.

There is no national initiative process. Citizens cannot directly propose federal laws or amendments to the U.S. Constitution through a ballot. Changes to the U.S. Constitution must go through the Article V process.

How a Citizen Initiative Works: Step by Step

While rules vary by state, the general process looks like this:

1. Draft the measure. Write the proposed law or amendment, ideally with legal review.

2. File with the state. Submit the text to the designated state official, often the secretary of state or attorney general.

3. Receive a ballot title and summary. The state may prepare an official title and summary that will appear on petitions and ballots.

4. Collect signatures. Gather the required number of valid signatures from registered voters, usually a percentage of votes cast in a recent election, within a set deadline. Some states also require signatures to be spread across different regions.

5. Submit and verify. Election officials check the signatures for validity.

6. Campaign. Educate voters about the measure.

7. Vote. If approved by voters, the measure becomes law.

Strengths of People-Led Legislation

Criticisms and Challenges

How Citizens Can Get Involved

You do not need to launch a statewide campaign to take part in people-led legislation. You can:

Make your voice part of a larger movement. The People’s Convention for Justice and Equality brings citizens together to pursue constitutional reform. Explore membership.

Ready to go further? Read how to start a constitutional reform petition in your state and see which states allow citizen initiatives and referendums before you commit to a campaign.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a citizen initiative?

A process that allows citizens to propose a new law or constitutional amendment by collecting enough voter signatures to place it on the ballot.

What is the difference between an initiative and a referendum?

An initiative proposes a new law. A popular referendum lets voters approve or reject a law the legislature has already passed.

Can citizens propose federal laws by initiative?

No. There is no national initiative process in the United States.

How many signatures are needed for a ballot initiative?

It varies by state, usually calculated as a percentage of votes cast in a recent election, and is often higher for constitutional amendments than for statutes.

Can an approved ballot initiative be overturned?

Yes. Courts can strike down measures that violate the state or federal constitution, and in many states the legislature can amend initiated statutes.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. For guidance on a specific situation, consult a licensed attorney in your state.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *