Most changes to a state constitution happen in one of two ways: lawmakers propose an amendment, or citizens collect signatures to put one on the ballot. But in some states, there is a third path built directly into the constitution itself. Every 10, 16, or 20 years, voters are automatically asked a simple question: should we hold a convention to revise our state constitution?
This process is called an automatic ballot referral. This article explains how it works, which states use it, how it differs from the federal Article V process, and why some reformers see it as a model for giving citizens a regular, guaranteed voice in constitutional change.
What Is an Automatic Ballot Referral?
An automatic ballot referral is a ballot measure that appears before voters without requiring a vote of the legislature or a citizen petition drive. The most common type is the state constitutional convention question.
In states with this provision, the constitution itself requires the question to appear on the ballot at set intervals. Lawmakers cannot block it, and citizens do not need to gather signatures. If a majority of voters say yes, the state moves forward with electing delegates to a convention that can propose changes to the constitution.
Which States Use Automatic Ballot Referrals?
Fourteen states provide for an automatic constitutional convention question:
- Every 10 years: Alaska, Hawaii, Iowa, New Hampshire, and Rhode Island
- Every 16 years: Michigan
- Every 20 years: Connecticut, Illinois, Maryland, Missouri, Montana, New York, Ohio, and Oklahoma.
Upcoming questions include Connecticut, Hawaii, and Illinois in 2028, and Iowa, Maryland, and Montana in 2030. Michigan’s question appeared on the ballot on November 3, 2026.
One notable exception is Oklahoma. Although its constitution calls for the question every 20 years, Oklahoma has not placed it on the ballot since 1970.
How the Process Works
1. The question appears automatically on the statewide general election ballot in the required year.
2. Voters decide whether to call a constitutional convention.
3. If voters approve, the state elects delegates, usually by district.
4. Delegates meet to debate and draft proposed changes to the state constitution.
5. Voters ratify or reject the proposed changes in a later election.
This final step is important. A convention can propose changes, but in most states voters must approve them before they take effect.
Why These Questions Usually Fail
In recent decades, voters have usually rejected convention questions. In 2017, for example, New York voters rejected a convention by a wide margin. Common reasons include:
- Uncertainty about what a convention might change
- Concerns about cost
- Opposition from groups worried about losing existing protections
- Low public awareness about what the question means
Supporters argue that the regular vote itself has value: it forces a public conversation about whether the state’s foundational law still serves its people.
How This Differs From an Article V Convention
The U.S. Constitution has its own convention process under Article V. Congress must call a convention for proposing amendments when two-thirds of state legislatures (34 states) apply for one.
Any amendment proposed by such a convention would still need ratification by three-fourths of the states (38).
Key differences:
- State conventions are triggered by voters directly through automatic referrals. Article V conventions are triggered by state legislatures.
- No Article V convention has ever been held. Every one of the 27 amendments to the U.S. Constitution was proposed by Congress.
PCFJE’s Approach to Ballot-Based Reform
PCFJE does not propose replacing the automatic referral model. It supports the wider family of ballot tools that give citizens a direct voice, including initiatives, referenda, citizen amendments, and automatic ballot referrals, and it treats state constitutional conventions and the Article V process as lawful routes to constitutional change.
The organization’s published platform calls for American citizens to prepare and propose legislation that enforces the Constitution, and it states that an Article V convention remains the path to national reform. PCFJE also promotes proposals that citizens could advance through the initiative process in states that allow it, such as a Home Equity Reform ballot measure that would let homeowners refinance based on home equity at a rate about one percentage point below the current mortgage rate.
Arguments For and Against Automatic Ballot Referrals
Supporters argue:
[CONFIRM: Describe the specific automatic ballot referral or convention process PCFJE or Anthony Gantt proposes. What would it do, at what level (state or federal), how often, and why? Use the client’s own description or direct quotes.] [CONFIRM: How this proposal relates to the existing state model described above.] Arguments For and Against Automatic Ballot Referrals Supporters argue:
- They guarantee citizens a regular voice in constitutional change, regardless of whether lawmakers act
- They provide a check on legislatures that may resist reforms affecting their own power
Critics argue:
- They provide a check on legislatures that may resist reforms affecting their own power Critics argue:
- Conventions can be expensive and unpredictable
- Well-funded interest groups may dominate delegate elections
- Existing rights could be put at risk if a convention’s scope is not limited
- Voters may not have enough information to make an informed choice
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an automatic ballot referral?
A ballot measure that a state constitution requires to appear on the ballot at set times, without a legislative vote or citizen petition. The most common type asks voters whether to hold a state constitutional convention.
How many states have automatic constitutional convention questions?
Fourteen states: Alaska, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maryland, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New Hampshire, New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, and Rhode Island.
What happens if voters approve a constitutional convention?
The state elects delegates who meet to propose changes to the constitution. In most states, those changes must then be approved by voters.
Has there ever been an Article V convention?
No. All 27 amendments to the U.S. Constitution were proposed by Congress, not by a convention.
Which states vote on a constitutional convention in 2028?
Connecticut, Hawaii, and Illinois are scheduled to ask voters in 2028.
This article is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. For guidance on a specific situation, consult a licensed attorney in your state.