Every time a court strikes down a law as unconstitutional, it relies on a power that appears nowhere explicitly in the Constitution. That power, known as judicial review, was established in 1803 in one of the most important cases in American history: Marbury v. Madison.

This article explains the political conflict behind the case, what the Supreme Court decided, how Chief Justice John Marshall reasoned his way to judicial review, and why the decision matters to every citizen who wants to challenge an unconstitutional law.

The Political Background

The election of 1800 was one of the most bitter in American history. President John Adams and his Federalist Party lost control of both the presidency and Congress to Thomas Jefferson and the Democratic-Republicans.

In the final weeks before leaving office, the Federalists moved to keep influence in the one branch they still controlled: the courts. Congress created new judicial positions, and Adams appointed loyal Federalists to fill them. Among these appointments were dozens of justices of the peace for the District of Columbia. They became known as the “midnight judges” because some were confirmed in Adams’s final hours in office.

The Undelivered Commission

William Marbury was one of those appointees. His commission was signed and sealed but not delivered before Adams left office. The Secretary of State responsible for delivering it was John Marshall, who had also just been appointed Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

When Jefferson took office, his new Secretary of State, James Madison, refused to deliver the remaining commissions. Marbury went directly to the Supreme Court, asking it to issue a writ of mandamus, a court order requiring Madison to deliver his commission. Marbury relied on Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789, which he argued gave the Supreme Court power to issue such writs in cases brought directly before it.

The Dilemma Facing Chief Justice Marshall

Marshall faced a difficult position. If the Court ordered Madison to deliver the commission, the Jefferson administration would likely ignore it, exposing the Court as powerless. If the Court refused, it would appear to be bowing to political pressure.

What the Court Decided

Marshall’s opinion, issued on February 24, 1803, answered three questions:

1. Did Marbury have a right to his commission? Yes. Once signed and sealed, the appointment was complete.

2. Did the law provide a remedy? Yes. Where there is a legal right, there must be a legal remedy.

3. Could the Supreme Court issue the writ? No. The third answer was the critical one. Marshall reasoned that Article III of the Constitution defines the limited types of cases the Supreme Court can hear directly, known as its original jurisdiction. Section 13 of the Judiciary Act tried to expand that jurisdiction beyond what the Constitution allowed.

Congress cannot change the Constitution through ordinary legislation, so that part of the Judiciary Act was unconstitutional and void.

The Birth of Judicial Review

In reaching that result, Marshall declared the principle that defines American constitutional law:

“It is emphatically the province and duty of the Judicial Department to say what the law is.”

His reasoning was straightforward:

Marbury never received his commission. But by giving up a small power, the Court claimed a much larger one: the authority to review the constitutionality of acts of Congress.

Was Judicial Review a New Idea?

Not entirely. Alexander Hamilton had argued in Federalist No. 78 that courts should treat the Constitution as fundamental law and set aside conflicting statutes. Some state courts had already exercised similar power. Marbury established the principle firmly at the federal level.

Judicial Review After Marbury

The Supreme Court did not strike down another act of Congress until Dred Scott v. Sandford in 1857.

Over time, judicial review expanded significantly:

Why Marbury v. Madison Matters to Citizens Today

Judicial review is what allows individuals to challenge unconstitutional laws in court. When citizens bring cases arguing that a law violates free speech, due process, or equal protection, they rely on the principle Marshall announced in 1803: that the Constitution is supreme and courts must enforce it over conflicting laws.

Without judicial review, constitutional rights would depend entirely on the goodwill of legislatures and executives.

Join citizens working for constitutional accountability. The People’s Convention for Justice and Equality educates and organizes Americans to defend their constitutional rights. Explore membership.

Explore the full article archive for more plain-language guides to the cases and clauses that decide how your rights are enforced.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Marbury v. Madison establish?

It established judicial review, the power of federal courts to declare laws unconstitutional and refuse to enforce them.

Who won Marbury v. Madison?

Technically, Madison. The Court agreed Marbury had a right to his commission but held it lacked the power to order its delivery because the law granting that power was unconstitutional.

Is judicial review in the Constitution?

Not explicitly. It was established through Chief Justice John Marshall’s reasoning in Marbury v. Madison, based on the Constitution’s status as supreme law.

Why is Marbury v. Madison important?

It made the courts a check on the other branches and gave citizens a way to challenge unconstitutional laws.

When was Marbury v. Madison decided?

February 24, 1803.

This article is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. For guidance on a specific situation, consult a licensed attorney in your state.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *